Aristotle’s Criticism of Presocratic Philosophy · Harold F. Cherniss. New York: Octagon Books (). Abstract, This article has no associated abstract. (fix it). Harold F. Cherniss [was] a specialist in ancient Greek philosophy who wrote many books and articles in his field and was an editor and translator of volumes. Harold Cherniss () was an American Classicist. A highly renowned academic, Cherniss received his Ph.D. in Greek, Latin, and Sanskrit from the.

Author: Akimi Mezihn
Country: Seychelles
Language: English (Spanish)
Genre: Art
Published (Last): 18 October 2011
Pages: 186
PDF File Size: 11.55 Mb
ePub File Size: 19.82 Mb
ISBN: 744-9-17661-538-3
Downloads: 35918
Price: Free* [*Free Regsitration Required]
Uploader: Kigagami

Erik marked it as to-read May 10, In Plato studies, ‘unitarianism’ is the view that Plato’s dialogues contain a unified and systematic philosophy. Cherniss’s close friend and colleague, the art historian Erwin Panofsky’considered the case a symbolic and sorry indictment of American society.

Lists with This Book. Tate – – The Classical Review 60 hatold The computer was a practical undertaking but the Institute was not conceived of as a place for anything practical. Dherniss, accessed on January 9,at GoogleBooks.

Harold F. Cherniss

Cherniss put ‘OctoberBaltimore’ at the end of the preface of his Aristotle’s Criticism of Plato and the Academy Books by Harold F. When Oppenheimer asked me what I would do with such a passage, I began stumbling, and he said, “Well that’s very stupid.

John Bigelow – manuscript. Landry – – Philosophia Mathematica 20 2: Open Preview See a Problem? The letter was signed by H. Harold Cherniss married Ruth Meyer Cherniss in Return to Book Page. The remarks were of such a nature that they caused Cherniss to develop an intense dislike for the man. Graham said that Cherniss. The Russian government then adopted a systematic policy of excluding Jews from their economic and public roles, and this provoked a mass emigration of Jewish refugees from Russia to the United States and other countries.


From the passages thus far considered there emerge certain general tendencies of Aristotle’s critical method … Essential distinctions among various Academic theories are likely to be disregarded, and a criticism pertinent to one form of a given doctrine may be applied to all of its variations … and, finally, a doctrine may be attacked in a form which is the cuerniss of Aristotle’s own interpretation and formulation … [76].

Lewis Strauss sought to have Oppenheimer fired:. Arntzenius, cjerniss for Advanced Study: Cherniss spoke at a memorial service for Erwin Panofsky, a colleague at the Institute for Advanced Study, and said the ‘strong but subtle joys of private friendship that he afforded are too sensitive to endure expression …’ [53].

I don’t recall how he characterized the remarks, but Solmsen’s description of the antidemocratic, anti-Catholic, anti-Semitic Prussian lens through which Wilamowitz viewed Weimar Germany would explain Cherniss’s antipathy. From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia.

Harold F. Cherniss – Wikipedia

He spent most of his time maintaining his elaborate bibliography of Plato, carefully entering the information on each new book and article on an index card. InOppenheimer accepted an offer to take up the directorship of the Institute for Advanced Study. Chernisw and the Coming of Wisdom in Ancient Greece.


Cherniss was thus said cyerniss be ‘the heir and apologist of Shorey’s interpretation of the dherniss of Plato’s thought. Cherniss demonstrated ‘in detail how much of the conceptual apparatus often attributed to Presocratic thinkers in fact represents Aristotle’s own reformulation of their theories in terms of his own philosophy.

The Protestant approach, by contrast, commits itself to the sufficiency of the dialogues for determining that philosophy. Science Logic and Mathematics. Cherniss was the first member of faculty Oppenheimer appointed to the Institute.

Continuum International,p.

It is opposed, for example, to ‘developmentalism’ that holds Plato’s doctrines evolved through the decades in which he wrote the dialogues. Kafkasfriend rated it really liked it Dec 13, The Protestant approach rejects this testimony on the grounds that the dialogues themselves do not confirm it. Afterwards Cherniss invited me to his beautiful office and, as we started chatting, Oppenheimer came into the room and sat on the table behind us.

I would still start with Riddle of the Early Academy, however. Cherniss was seeking a young man who had betrayed scores in the Belgian and French undergrounds to the German occupation. View all 5 comments. Thus, the contents of the dialogues always trump testimony.